Ratings and Reviews of Sonic Drive-In Peanut Butter Shake

This recipe is quick, easy, and delicious! Will be using this again.

Great recipe! We live overseas so can't go to a Sonic but this recipe is a way to get something from one of our favorite places. Thanks!

I made the milkshake with both the fudge sauce and the peanut butter. I used a homemade fudge sauce that I make, and it was DELICIOUS! They are habit forming.

I altered the recipe a bit. To start I used cookie dough ice cream instead of vanilla, chocolate milk instead of regular, and crunchy peanut butter, and it's the best I have ever tasted. Don't know if it has been done but I call it the "Reese's Pieces Shake." Give her a shot.

I loved it! I too am a peanut butter freak! I used fudge swirl ice cream because that was my only option, but next time I'm using chocolate, because I'm also a chocolate freak (most women are, right?)

These shakes are both SO good and so easy to make...what a hit! I tried 1 TB of Hershey's syrup - didn't have fudge sauce, and it was great!

I used Breyer's 98% fatfree ice cream with this and skim milk. It was a real treat and not such a bad cheat on my diet. Thanks for the recipe.

I added 2 Tbsp of powdered malt - might as well go whole hog with something this good/bad. It was absolutely fantastic!!

Good Recipe. Gives the "ratio" of measurment that lets you "duplicate" the taste of Sonic. Acutally only takes "multiple clicks" if you don't know how to use your computer... *ahem* Excellent recipe overall!

Its good, and I love this site...however, I agree with another person on here about "top secret"? This is a pretty simple thing you don't have to search for on the web. Todd, please bring on the real top secret stuff...thanks!