Ratings and Reviews of American Coney Island Chili Dogs (Detroit Coney Island Sauce)
By Todd Wilbur
Reviews
Nicole Grady
Sep 14, 2025, 18:15
Fantastic!
Jessica W
Aug 15, 2023, 11:24
This was fantastic! My husband LOVES coney dogs and the place he buys them is 50 min away so I tried this recipe. He loves it and I was able to freeze some of the left overs for his next craving. It looks really really runny when you first start the simmer. Let it do it’s thing and it cooks down to a delicious thick chili over time.
rebecca McKay
Apr 24, 2023, 15:01
This recipe is on point. I had to change up the tallow bc I was doing this recipe without much prep but even still it REALLY tastes the same. So pleased!!!!

.png)

